NefMoto

Noob Zone => Noob Questions => Topic started by: curamrdan on April 27, 2021, 11:39:43 AM



Title: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 27, 2021, 11:39:43 AM
Hi, experiencing problem on racecar 1.8t with sequential gearbox, using external box, which cuts power for ignition coils. Issue is, after shifts, ecu goes to some limp mode and WGDC are zero for some limited time - say 10-20sec (boost request is still there, no DTC).
Have you any tips for me?


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: cessnas on April 27, 2021, 01:44:21 PM
Probarbly the only way to stop this happening is to numb knock recgonition(See the S4Wiki). This is a really bad idea though since the knock sensor will not do anything even when not shifting, so it can cause serious engine damadge.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: nyet on April 27, 2021, 02:24:17 PM
The only "safe" way to do this is somehow signal the ECU to turn off knock recognition during the cut (similar to what some LC/NLS ASM hack functions do), which likely would requiring wiring an input pin and a good amount of ASM.

I would not recommend numbing KR unless this car is always running race gas or E85


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 27, 2021, 03:02:19 PM
There is zero KR during shift cut(maybe already in limp at that moment?). It happends also when i shifting with clutch(=closed throttle, but box still cutting coil power source)
Tried to find any "endstuf" diagnostic codeword for ignition coils, but found nothing in ME7.5(wideband). Will try to rise DZUEET counters, but its just shot in the dark.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: nyet on April 27, 2021, 03:32:18 PM
Ah. Then it is not KR related. Probably ignition DTC related.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: justinvw2646 on April 27, 2021, 03:33:34 PM
Will your box allow removal of ground instead of B+? Might be worth a try to see if it makes any difference.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: BlackT on April 27, 2021, 08:05:01 PM
Log would be nice.
Did you change ESKONF?
CL codeword?


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 28, 2021, 01:28:59 AM
Box is simple, just cutting wire feeded into it and potentiometer for time adjustment.
In eskonf means zeroing or 11  ZUEs?  I did not touch it yet, but good idea.
CL codeword, do not know what it is...?

Log is here, first pulls and last pulls are with box disconnected, middle  signle shift is with box connected and only situation when problem happends. All is normal shifting, not flat/wot shift.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: prj on April 28, 2021, 03:07:40 AM
Restore all fault classes to stock and the ECU will most of the time literally tell you what the problem is.

Another thing which will cause a load cut is if the ECU sees lean mixture during WOT.
Which it will see, because you're cutting spark, so a ton of oxygen hits the sensor.

And then we get back to the same point.
If you had the skills to solve this, you would not be even using an external box, because the ECU can do this much better based on an input.
Either way what you are trying to do most likely will require code mods to the firmware.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: d3irb on April 28, 2021, 09:38:40 AM
Hi, experiencing problem on racecar 1.8t with sequential gearbox, using external box, which cuts power for ignition coils. Issue is, after shifts, ecu goes to some limp mode and WGDC are zero for some limited time - say 10-20sec (boost request is still there, no DTC).
Have you any tips for me?

Strongly recommend you get rid of any external box and look at NLS patches. You basically want to trigger NLS on an external input that happens not to be the clutch pedal (load cell or whatever you're using for sequential shift detection).

The only way you will fix this issue effectively is by editing the software. Editing the calibration is not going to fix this for you without breaking something else. So, you might as well use the existing patches to the software that accomplish what you want.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 28, 2021, 10:13:19 AM
Tested eskonf coding, and some different settings, none of them had an effect.
When i shift in WOT, seems immediately as cut happends, throttle is closing and then goes back, it looks like normal shifting on log, but it was not.
Tried classic NLS patch some time ago(before car owner installed cutbox), and it was not worked as expected...like it was not cutting fast enought. Its is hewland gearbox with SQS sequential shifter, design of cut switch is not perfect, just my opinion.

So im giving up. 


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 28, 2021, 10:22:08 AM
If i decide to give a NSL patch another shot. How to overcome 2 things?:

1. car has no speed sensor , when i set speed treshold to zero, i will not work if i remmeber correctly.
2. gear cut switch is just momentary ,it will not cover whole time of shifting process like on clutch pedal.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: _nameless on April 28, 2021, 12:41:07 PM
If i decide to give a NSL patch another shot. How to overcome 2 things?:

1. car has no speed sensor , when i set speed treshold to zero, i will not work if i remmeber correctly.
2. gear cut switch is just momentary ,it will not cover whole time of shifting process like on clutch pedal.


I have a solution if needed pm me


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: BlackT on April 28, 2021, 12:49:05 PM
1.You can make NLS routine without speed signal
2. NLS patch work cut ignition for 200 mS, most  drivers can't shift in this range, but still make to shift on WOT, engine does not produce powerr so fast


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: prj on April 28, 2021, 04:37:38 PM
The NLS patch on here is stupid, designed only to make flames out of the exhaust.
You need a cut based on strain gauge and not one which has timers and what not, but which completely cuts everything out until the shift is complete.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: nyet on April 28, 2021, 04:40:43 PM
The NLS patch on here is stupid, designed only to make flames out of the exhaust.
You need a cut based on strain gauge and not one which has timers and what not, but which completely cuts everything out until the shift is complete.

I agree, the right way to do this is with a dedicated input signal from the trans, and not via timer.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 29, 2021, 01:47:49 PM
Strain gauge is not an option here, gear sensor inside gearbox also.

Is there somebody, who can modify or make new "NLS" patch for me?

Work simply with zero speed, when recieve a clutch switch impulse, simply cut ignition for say 150ms - no matter of clutch switch state during this timer.
Block next cut(whole function) say 500ms after prevousion cut.
If i remmeber correctly, standard clutch switch is closed and opening when pedal is pressed. My switch on gear knob is reversed, its closing during shift. So reverse the logic to avoid some relay wiring(ect potential delaying of input).
Edit error checking for DTC of clutch pedal switch...
Cure Knock control ect...


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: prj on April 29, 2021, 02:57:34 PM
You don't need a timer if you use clutch switch input, simply while it's pressed cut, and once it's not pressed anymore release.
This will work absolutely fine.

The timer with the "bounce" is what is messing everything up.


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: _nameless on April 29, 2021, 02:59:20 PM
You don't need a timer if you use clutch switch input, simply while it's pressed cut, and once it's not pressed anymore release.
This will work absolutely fine.

The timer with the "bounce" is what is messing everything up.
this 100%


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: fknbrkn on April 29, 2021, 04:00:26 PM
Post your file
Could be some lkvdk issue?
did you FFed LKVDKMN and KFVPDKLD ?


Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: curamrdan on April 29, 2021, 04:29:13 PM
Problem with switch is that is on SQS shifter:
http://www.sqsracing.com/produkt/4:4:sqs-sequential-shifter-sss-kaps-vw-audi-seat-skoda

Signal dissapier during time when revolver system inside shifting the gear, no after that. And gear knob is mechanicaly disconnected after succesful shift, even its is still pulled backward. So maybe, without timer, it will be usable, when we buy the gearknob with internal microswitches and use them instead switch on revolver system?
http://www.sqsracing.com/produkt/319:414:hgk-sck-shift-cut-lever-power-knob-flatshifter-strain-gauge-quickshifter-blip-throttle


funebroken: i know what you mean, i met this kind softlimp already on different car. But this one is mafless , KFVP.. is maxed , LKV... is not touched(400rpm) and without cutting is no problem.



Title: Re: Problem with external GearCut device on ME7.5 racecar
Post by: nyet on April 29, 2021, 07:06:20 PM
But this one is mafless

SMH