I am not sure about the details - maybe it just had older PCB swapped. The only thing I know it is really hard to swap clusters in A3/S3 as even sometimes within same model year clusters made for other engines does not work in other cars...
Golf/Octavia/Passat/SuperB - no problems, you can even swap A6 C5 cluster into A4 B5.5 most of the time, but A3/S3 gives terrible headache most of the time